The Auditor: Most states have a State Auditor, also known as a comptroller, who audits departments of the government, looking for fraud, waste, and abuse. The US has a similar office, the Government Accountability Office (GAO), headed by the Comptroller General. The GAO is supposed to be part of the legislative branch of government and actually occupies a murky space between the executive and legislative branches. The GAO also has the sole power under the current Impoundment Control Act to sue to release illegal impoundments. To avoid inappropriate political influence the Comptroller General is appointed to a 15 year term. Unfortunately, that term ended in 2025, and Donald Trump has thwarted any action by refusing to appoint a replacement. The prior Comptroller General remains in office but is unwilling to take such an action without authorization by Congress, which the Republican-controlled Congress is naturally unwilling to give. Each US executive agency has its own Inspector General to perform a similar role, with 30-day notice to Congress required before firing. Naturally Trump has blown past that requirement with mass firings.
So, how to prevent the President from neutering the office of Comptroller General by not appointing an officer? Make the office elective, of course. Many states do it after all. Elect a National Auditor to head the GAO, with the power to sue in case of illegal withholding of funds. Allow the recipient to sue for release of funds if the Auditor fails to do so after a certain period of time (I am open to persuasion as to how long). Consider criminal penalties for illegal withholding of funds. Executive agencies can keep their Inspector Generals but let the Auditor have parallel offices. The Auditor would investigate the offices of the President and the Attorney General and the Treasurer for fraud, waste, and abuse, issue reports, and recommend reforms, as is the case now. "Abuse" would mean not just financial abuse, but all abuse of office.
Would the office have any teeth? Certainly, it would have (as it has now) power to sue for the release of illegal withholding of funds. Add to that power to sue to block illegal disbursement of funds. I would give it the power, not only to make reports and recommend reforms, but to make referrals for criminal prosecution to the Attorney General if it spotted actual criminality by government officials. Unlike the Presidency or Treasury, the Auditor could only investigate and make criminal referrals for federal employees, not private citizens.
I would give the office another set of teeth as well. The most dangerous decision by the Supreme Court since it held that (Republican) Presidents could not be prosecuted for crimes committed as part of their "official duties" was Trump v. Slaughter, which struck down at least some laws limiting the President's power to fire federal officials. Slaughter gave the President unlimited power to fire members of multi-member boards. How far this decision goes is unclear, but it has at least the potential to remove all civil service protections and make all federal employees subject to termination at will by the President. Now consider that the Supreme Court has protected the (Republican) President from all prosecution for crimes committed in office and the Constitution gives the President unlimited power to pardon federal crimes -- including crimes he ordered! Now add to that the power to fire any employee who refuses an order to commit a crime and the rule of law is lost altogether.
At present, civil service protections remain in place, but any employee claiming improper firing must first take the case to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPS). But the MSPS is a three-member board, meaning that Trump can fire its members and replace them with ones who can be trusted to rule in his favor! Admittedly there is appeal to the courts, who now await the Supreme Court's decree. I have already proposed as part of my reform that the President not be allowed to pardon federal employees. Civil service protections should also be guaranteed as part of my proposed reform. And the board deciding whether firings violate civil service protections should be moved to the Auditor. This would include firings by the President, Attorney General, or Treasurer.
Interaction among the four offices: I would give all four offices four-year terms. Americans are used to four-year terms, and I am inclined to agree. The number has become so pervasive at least in part because it works well. Limits to two terms are also well-engrained, both at the federal and state levels, so they will probably apply to the other three offices as well. The President is required to be a natural born citizen. I see no reason to apply this restriction to the Attorney General, Treasurer, and Auditor. Nine years of citizenship is good enough for Senators and should be good enough for the other three executive offices. In addition to taking away the President's power to pardon federal employees, I would make the statute of limitations for all crimes by federal employees in the course of their office to five years, i.e., past the term of the current Attorney General. That should give everyone second thoughts about taking any illegal action while in office.
And while I hate to have to raise the issue, Elon Musk and his DOGE have made clear that IT is immensely important, maybe even to the extent of being a proper topic for my proposed constitutional amendments, and certainly important enough to include in any enabling statutes. IT for the President, Attorney General, and Treasurer must be wholly separate, so as not to allow one to invade the domain of the other. The relatively toothless Auditor is a different matter. The Auditor personnel should have the ability to enter the departments they are inspecting and have read-only access to records, but not the power to exclude employees of the audited agency, or to change anything in its system.
Finally, there is the matter of staggered terms. If all four officers are elected at the same time as part of a common slate, they can coordinate actions and perhaps collude on illegal plans. If they are too opposed to each other, it could lead to complete governmental paralysis. One option is to elect all four offices at the same time. Ticket splitting would be allowed, but I suspect it would be decidedly rare. Another option would be to elect the President every four years and the other three in the midterms. This would tend to make the other three aligned against the President and risk paralysis. A third option would be to elect the President and Auditor (the least powerful of the four) in Presidential years and the Attorney General and Treasurer at the midterms. Finally, one could elect one such office each year. My inclination is to favor the third option, but I am open to persuasion.
So, I am proposing a President to handle foreign and military matters, allocation of funds within executive discretion, enacting regulations, and investigations. The Attorney General would handle all law enforcement, criminal prosecutions, and major civil enforcement. The Treasurer would disburse funds, decide whether disputed funds should be disbursed, and withhold funds applied to an illegal use. The Auditor would perform audits, make reports, recommend reforms, refer public officials for prosecution, sue for the release of illegally impounded funds and to block diversion of funds to an unauthorized purpose, and determine whether firings by the other executive departments were legal.
Undoubtedly, I am overlooking problems my system would cause. I am open to input.



No comments:
Post a Comment